FIDA CONDEMNS AYADE’S DECSION ON CROSS RIVER CHIEF JUDGE, ALLEGES BIAS AGAINST WOMEN

Ben Ayade

International Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA) has condemned the failure of rhe Cross River State Governor, Prof. Ben Ayade, and the state Assembly to confirm Justice Akon Ikpeme as chief justice because of her state of birth.

Ayade had on Tuesday sworn in Justice Maurice Eneji as the Acting Chief Judge of the state following the expiration of the tenure of Justice Ikpeme on Monday because the State Assemly refused to confirm her appointment based on the fact that her state of birth is Akwa Ibom even though she is married to a man from Cross River.

In a statement jointly signed by the Country Vice President/National President, FIDA Nigeria,
Rhoda Prevail Tyoden, and National Publicity Secretary, Eliana Martins, the group described the refusal to confirm Ikpeme as CJ as an
act of grave infringement of her human rights

FIDA said it was heart-breaking to note that discrimination on grounds of ethnicity and political zoning could happen at this point of the struggle to stop all forms of discrimination in the society.

The group noted that Ikpeme who had served meritoriously as acting CJ since March 12, 2019, following the retirement of Hon Justice Michael Edem, was born in Cross River, married a Cross Riverian, started her career with the Cross-River State Ministry of Justice and rose to the position o Director of Public Prosecution before her appointment as a judge in the state.

It added that even her father was a permanent secretary in Cross River and retired in the state.

Noting that Ikpeme is the most senior judge in the state, FIDA consequently called on Governor Ayade and the lawmakers to reverse their action and confirm her as CJ.

The statement reads:

“The attention of the International Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA) Nigeria has been drawn to an act of grave infringement of the human rights of Hon. Justice Akon Ikpeme by the Governor of Cross River State and some members of the State House of Assembly.

“It is heart-breaking to note that at this point of our struggle to stop all forms of discrimination in our society, we will be awakened to such discrimination on grounds of ethnicity and political zoning.

“Hon. Justice Akon Ikpeme has been the Acting Chief Judge of the state since March 12, 2019, following the retirement of Hon Justice Michael Edem. She has served meritoriously and despite several challenges along the way has accomplished and received a commendation from the Honourable President of the Court of Appeal, Hon. Justice Z. A. Bulkachuwa (CFR) as she then was, for her immense contribution towards achieving a sustainable and independent democracy in Nigeria.

“Hon Justice Akon Ikpeme is an indigene of Akwa Ibom State but was born in Cross River State. She married a Cross Riverian blessed with children; She started her career with the Cross-River State Ministry of Justice and rose to the position o Director of Public Prosecution and further appointed a Judge in Cross River State. Even her father was a permanent secretary in Cross River and retired here. Her state of indigene cannot now be used against her. We must not allow ethnicity and politics to be the deciding factor in the appointment of a Chief Judge of Cross River State.

“Justice Akon Ikpeme, being the most senior judge in the State, is the rightful person to act as Chief Judge of the State, since nothing else disqualifies her. The government cannot impose a junior based on tribalism and zoning. Issues such as geopolitical zoning, tribe have no place in evaluating this decision.

“Section 271(4) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended) confirms this position and is further supported by our legal professional rules of practice. The profession does not tolerate a deviation from the practice.

“FIDA Nigeria restates that discrimination based on the state of origin amounts to grave injustice being that the constitution says, ‘the most senior judge of the High Court… and not the most senior indigenous judge of the High Court’.

“Since there is no legal impediment against Hon Justice Akon Bassey Ikpeme who qualifies, we can conclude that the rule of law supports her confirmation.

“Section 271. (1) of the Constitution says “the Governor of the State shall make the appointment of a person to the office of Chief Judge of a State on the recommendation of the National Judicial Council subject to confirmation of the appointment by the House of Assembly of the State.

“The action of the Executive Governor of Cross River State in appointing a junior judge instead of the Hon Justice Akon B. Ikpeme, who is the next senior Judge in the hierarchy of Cross River State Judiciary is a grave injustice

“We, therefore, appeal to his Excellency, the Governor and the Speaker of the State House of Assembly to retract his action which is discriminatory and a breach of the constitution.

“FIDA condemns in its entirety the practice of Chief Executives of States attempting to impose their preferred candidates for an appointment either as Judges or Chief Judge of a state. The National Judicial Council is independent and should remain so; there is an order of precedence involving the appointment of a Chief Judge of the state.

“FIDA Nigeria unites with other groups in strongly condemning the undue interference and discrimination. This position is sad at a time like this when we are planning towards the celebration of the International Women’s Day, IWD themed: ‘Generation Equality: Realizing Women’s Rights’ … this is a clear infringement of the rights of an honourable woman.

“We, therefore, call on His Excellency, the Governor of Cross River State to do the right thing and prove to the world that he abhors all forms of discrimination by swearing in the most senior Judge who has been acting effectively.

“FIDA NIGERIA stands against all forms of discrimination and injustice. Let’s stop undue interference with the Judiciary and its processes. The independence of the Judiciary must be assured and guaranteed.”